HLHS: Restrictive Atrial Septum on Fetal Echo

Ratio = forward ÷ reverse pulmonary vein VTI. Lower means more left atrial hypertension. Studies define “restrictive” differently: each row says whose cut-off it is.

Pulmonary vein forward/reverse VTI

RatioWhat it predictedSource
≤2.7Severe illness within 2 h of birth: sensitivity 89%, specificity 97%, AUC 0.93. Also predicted emergent septal intervention and death or transplant Gellis 2018
≤3Emergency atrial septostomy: no false positives (≤5 had 2), sensitivity unchanged. Late second-trimester values stayed on the same side of the cut-off in 30 of 32 Divanović 2011
<3Guideline cut-off for needing the septum opened urgently after birth. Missed some in one cohort: sensitivity 60%, specificity 100% (Mardy 2021)AHA 2014; ASE 2023, Table 13
<5Emergency atrial septoplasty: sensitivity 88%, specificity 97%, AUC 0.98 Michelfelder 2005, Table 3
<5.1Any septal procedure before stage 1: sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%, AUC 0.98. Did not reliably predict 2-year survivalLowenthal 2012

AHA 2014, Class IIa (LOE B/C): with a restrictive or intact septum, planning specialized delivery room care is reasonable when the ratio is <3 or the third-trimester hyperoxia test is abnormal.

How to measure
  • Where: find the vein with colour, then pulsed Doppler with the sample volume in the vein just before it enters the left atrium, as parallel to flow as possible. Right or left vein. Lower the wall filter so slow flow shows (Michelfelder 2005, Divanović 2011).
  • What: forward VTI = systolic plus early diastolic waves; reverse VTI = the reversal with atrial contraction. Average several beats: Taketazu 2004 used three, Dannesbo 2026 both veins and three measurements.
  • When: ASE 2023 says measure it at every fetal echo in HLHS, with the last near term; follow-up every 4–8 weeks plus the late third trimester (Table 15).
  • Repeatability: the VTI measures varied 15–16% between and within observers (Michelfelder 2005). Values close to a cut-off are uncertain.
  • Direction: Taketazu 2004 prints the ratio the other way up, reverse ÷ forward (cut-off 0.18). Check which way a report gives it.
  • Grades used by later studies: 3–5 mild to moderate, <3 severe (Campbell 2026); Dannesbo 2026 puts the boundaries at ≤5 and ≤3.

Pulmonary vein flow pattern

PatternDoppler, and the newbornsSource
AContinuous forward flow, small atrial reversal (reverse ÷ forward <0.18). Postnatal foramen 4.5 ± 2.1 mmTaketazu 2004
BContinuous forward flow, larger atrial reversal (≥0.18). Postnatal foramen 1.6 ± 1.6 mmTaketazu 2004
CBrief to-and-fro flow, little or no diastolic flow. All 3 live-born had an intact septum and needed emergent septoplasty Taketazu 2004

With a decompressing vein

FindingWhat is reportedSource
How often12 of 195 HLHS fetuses; 22% of those with a ratio <5Campbell 2026
Ratio still countsWith a vein: ratio <3, 3 of 4 died; ≥3, 6 of 8 alive without transplant at 1 year. Once the ratio was known, the vein itself was not independently associated with outcome (12 with a vein; wide confidence interval). Journal pre-proofCampbell 2026

Maternal hyperoxygenation test

MeasureAbnormal result and what it predictedSource
Branch PA pulsatility indexNot vasoreactive: falls <10% at every site (last scan after 31 weeks); predicted immediate septal intervention, sensitivity 100%, specificity 94%, PPV 71%, NPV 100% Szwast 2010
Pulmonary vein ratioRatio <6.5 on oxygen: emergent septoplasty, sensitivity and specificity 100%. Baseline 3–7: a ratio that falls on oxygen separated the groups Mardy 2021

ASE 2023: may be considered in select cases in the late third trimester.

How it was done
  • Oxygen: 100% by non-rebreather mask at 8 L/min (about FiO2 60%) for 10 minutes, then repeat the Doppler (both studies). Szwast also rechecked after 5 minutes off, about 30 minutes in all, and saw no adverse effects.
  • PA sites (Szwast): proximal branch just past the duct, the last segment before the lung, and the first branch point inside the lung. Ductal and umbilical PI rechecked.
  • Cut-off: the 10% was chosen from that cohort; normal fetuses respond only after about 31 weeks. Two fetuses restrictive by previously published criteria did respond late and did not need urgent intervention.

Septal anatomy and the lungs

FindingWhat is reportedSource
Left atrial sizeRatio ≤5 (54 fetuses): hypoplastic LA in 61%, complex septum or a ridge across the LA 19%, near-normal LA 17% (never intact), dilated LA with severe MR 4%Dannesbo 2026
Lymphangiectasia on fetal MRISeen with every septal type; went with a lower ratioDannesbo 2026
Nutmeg lung, outcome4 of 44 HLHS fetal MRIs; all 4 died by 5 months (35% death or transplant without it)Saul 2016
Intact septum after birthSmall LA with a thick muscular septum: 4 of 18, all with obstructed decompression and the worst lung histologyRychik 1999

Delivery planning

ItemWhat is said or reportedSource
Level of careLevel 4: caesarean in a cardiac facility, usually at 38–39 weeks, cardiac team in the delivery room, plan for catheterization, surgery or ECMO. HLHS without restriction is level 2AHA 2014, Table 19
RecommendationSpecialized delivery room planning with a ratio <3 or an abnormal third-trimester hyperoxia test: Class IIa LOE B/CAHA 2014
Fetal echo as the screenHigh risk (ratio <3 near term, thick septum, foramen <3 mm) for intervention, ECMO or death within 2 h: sensitivity 100%, specificity 95%, PPV 71%, NPV 100%. Planned cardiac operating-room delivery: 4 of 5 survived, 0 of 2 born elsewhere Moray 2024
Emergent intervention within 24 hRestriction before 30 weeks, 11 of 13; from 30 weeks, 5 of 7; none, 4 of 174 Kikano 2026

Restriction can progress: 8 of 18 with comparable fetal and postnatal images were worse after birth than on the first fetal scan (Glatz 2007).

Outcomes for counselling

CohortWith restriction vs withoutSource
Prenatal, any restriction2-year survival 43% vs 83%, intention to treatLowenthal 2012
Left heart obstruction, ratio ≤3Survival to discharge 42% vs 81%; excess deaths mostly before stage 2Schneider 2020
Intact or <2 mm on colour30-day survival 38% (intact septum with mitral or aortic atresia) vs 94% (lesser obstruction)Glatz 2007
Septostomy in the first 2 daysMortality 48% before and soon after surgery, despite a successful septostomyVlahos 2004
Multicentre, stage 1Septal procedure before stage 1 vs no restriction: operative mortality adjusted OR 2.01, 1-year 2.2 (3,644 infants)Lin 2027
Timing of onset30-day mortality after stage 1: 25% (before 30 weeks), 29% (from 30 weeks), 6% (none), p 0.007. Overall postoperative mortality 58%, 29%, 40%, not significant Kikano 2026

Fetal atrial septal intervention

EvidenceWhat is said or reportedSource
RecommendationMay be considered for a severely restrictive or intact septum: Class IIb LOE B/CAHA 2014
Pooled studies746 fetuses: survival to discharge 37% with vs 52% without (no difference); restrictive septum at birth 38% vs 88%Mustafa 2024
Registry47 procedures: 13% procedure-related fetal death; discharge survival 34% with vs 36% withoutJantzen 2017
Single centreTechnically successful: survival 72% vs 21% for all others Yilmaz Furtun 2025
Defect sizeCreated defects ≥3 mm went with higher saturation and fewer procedures before surgeryMarshall 2008

Fetal HLHS and variants: predicting a restrictive or intact atrial septum, and what it means at birth

Key points

Why
  • Fetal foramen size did not predict postnatal size or need for septoplasty; the pulmonary vein pattern did (Taketazu 2004).
  • ASE 2023 asks for the ratio at every fetal echo in HLHS and its variants, with the last near term, to judge the risk of urgent intervention after birth.
  • After septostomy in the first 2 days, mortality before and soon after surgery was 48% (Vlahos 2004). Lung histology in intact septum shows dilated lymphatics and thickened (“arterialized”) pulmonary veins (Rychik 1999).
Sources and how this page was checked

Guidance (full text read in the parts used)

Studies (full text)

How it was checked